Abstract

AbstractNew entanglements between parenting (in theory and practice), environmentalism, religion, spirituality, and secularism are at the core of the analysis presented in this article. In francophone contexts, discourses by practitioners, advocates and detractors of natural parenting contribute to associating this specific style of parenting and several of its key practices with religion and spirituality. After documenting and defining natural parenting by listing its characteristic practices and underlining its values as well as its important overlap with attachment parenting, this article examines the historically religious roots of movements linked to several practices still regarded as typical of natural parenting (natural childbirth movements, natural family planning or fertility awareness, and breastfeeding advocacy). Along with feminist and medical strands of criticism, within these highly secular contexts, the association with religion and spirituality participates in the criticism of this style of parenting which combines the key tenets of attachment parenting with a strong environmentalist agenda implemented for the most part in the domestic sphere and around women’s bodies.

Highlights

  • Studying Natural Parenting from a Perspective of Religious StudiesIn francophone contexts, the association of “natural parenting” with religion or spirituality[1] is not always explicit but it is, pervasive

  • New entanglements between parenting, environmentalism, religion, spirituality, and secularism are at the core of the analysis presented in this article

  • Along with feminist and medical strands of criticism, within these highly secular contexts, the association with religion and spirituality participates in the criticism of this style of parenting which combines the key tenets of attachment parenting with a strong environmentalist agenda implemented for the most part in the domestic sphere and around women’s bodies

Read more

Summary

Introduction

The association of “natural parenting” with religion or spirituality[1] is not always explicit but it is, pervasive. Based on fieldwork conducted in the USA in the 1990s, before the rise of Internetbased communications and social media, her study examined the coherence of practices, discourses, and representations of what she and her informants called “natural mothering.” While building upon such previous works, this article apprehends natural parenting from a broader and more encompassing perspective in religious studies. In line with this blended methodology for data collection, this article, especially section 4, focuses on how media, especially in France, disseminate generally negative images about natural parenting that include references to religion or spirituality

Defining Natural Parenting
Defining Natural Parenting through Its Practices
Defining Natural Parenting through Its Underlying Values and Worldviews
Proximity
Natural Childbirth Movements
Breastfeeding Advocacy
References to Religion
Natural Parenting as Religious or Spiritual
Interview with Odile Buisson and Cartoons in Charlie Hebdo
Reviews of Movies on Homebirth
Findings
Concluding Remarks
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call