Automated high throughput DNA isolation for detection of human papillomavirus in oral rinse samples

Abstract

Background Oral HPV infection elevates risk of oropharyngeal cancer, but its natural history is unknown. Natural history studies necessitate validation of an automated, high-throughput method for HPV genomic DNA detection in oral rinse samples (ORS). Objectives To compare agreement of oral HPV detection in ORS processed by a magnetic-bead based automated platform to a previous gold-standard, manual protein-precipitation method. Agreement was compared to that of repeat sampling and repeat HPV testing. Study design HIV-infected individuals ( n = 100) provided two ORS collected 15 min apart. DNA was isolated from equal aliquots by either a protein-precipitation based (Puregene, Qiagen) or magnetic bead-based (QIAsymphony™ SP, Qiagen) method. HPV DNA was detected and type-specified by consensus primer PCR and reverse line blot hybridization. The kappa statistic was used to assess overall agreement (OA) and agreement on a positive test (Ps+). Results The DNA purification methods had very high agreement for categorizing an individual as HPV infected (OA = 0.95; Ps+ = 0.94) as well as for detection of HPV type-specific infection (OA = 0.99; Ps+ = 0.88) in ORS. Agreement for detection of HPV type-specific infection was greater than that observed with repeat oral rinse sampling (OA = 0.99, Ps+ = 0.76) but comparable to inter-assay agreement (OA = 1.00, Ps+ = 0.90). Conclusions HPV detection in ORS processed with a magnetic-bead based automated platform will facilitate large natural history studies of oral HPV infection necessary to evaluate the potential use of oral HPV detection in oral cancer screening.