AUTHOR'S REPLY

Abstract

An undesirable sensory attribute (“floral taint”) has been detected in red wines in North America, caused by leaves and petioles (materials other than grapes [MOG]) introduced during mechanical harvest after killing frosts. From 2017 to 2019, several harvest strategies were evaluated on Ontario Cabernet franc: hand harvest (HH), conventional machine harvesting (MECH), Braud-New Holland Opti (OPTI), Gregoire GL8, MECH + optical sorting (MECH+OS), and MECH with preharvest leaf removal (MECH+BLR). Concentrations of 41 odor-active compounds were quantified by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Harvest treatment effects varied by season. In 2017, HH resulted in lowest ethyl isobutyrate (MECH+BLR), ethyl nonoate, cis-linalool oxide (plus MECH and OPTI), trans-linalool oxide (plus MECH+OS), β-citral, and cis- and trans-rose oxide (plus MECH and OPTI). Ethyl hexanoate was lowest in MECH, and MECH+BLR, isoamyl hexanoate was lowest in all treatments except HH, and α-ionone was lowest in MECH and MECH+BLR. In 2018, HH resulted in the lowest β-damascenone, ethyl salicylate (plus OPTI and Gregoire), citronellol (plus Gregoire), cis- and trans-rose oxide (plus Gregoire), and eugenol (plus Gregoire). Isobutyl acetate, isoamyl hexanoate, and nerol were additionally reduced by Gregoire, and isopropylmethoxypyrazine was reduced by all treatments except HH. In 2019, harvest strategy affected 27 of 41 compounds, including 11 esters and 12 terpenes. Treatments leading to lowest concentrations were HH (nine compounds), MECH (eight compounds), MECH+BLR (10 compounds), OPTI (21 compounds), Gregoire (10 compounds), and MECH+OS (22 compounds). Wines from fruit that had undergone a killing frost contained different concentrations of 14 and eight compounds (2018), and 17 and 13 compounds (2019) for Cabernet franc and Cabernet Sauvignon, respectively. Results suggest that specific harvest technologies can reduce MOG and associated increases in aroma compounds, although seasonal differences may occur.