Atrial Fibrillation: Focal or Reentrant or Both?

Abstract

Ablation for atrial fibrillation (AF) is a genuinely viable and increasingly used option for improving quality of life in patients with symptomatic drug-refractory AF. What is remarkable about the limited success achieved with these procedures is that progress has occurred despite a near complete lack of knowledge about what causes or maintains AF. Focal origins for AF were first demonstrated decades ago1–4 with topical application of acetylcholine to junctional tissues and atrial sites triggering AF. More recently, there has been convincing documentation of rapid tachycardia arising from the pulmonary veins inciting AF, thus supporting the concept of “trigger elimination” contributing to the success of pulmonary vein isolation. However, studies also support the presence of multiple reentrant circuits maintaining and possibly initiating AF.5, 6 The ablation era has taught us7–9 that in persistent and chronic AF, trigger elimination alone is not enough and that substrate modification is probably necessary to decrease the likelihood of reentrant wavelet continuance and thereby increase success rates. Even the most ardent supporter of either hypothesis recognizes the limitations of each. How can a focal source exist in this milieu indefinitely, producing and maintaining chronic AF, and how do multiple reentrant wavelets arise spontaneously? Article see p 384 In this issue of Circulation: Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology , Niu et al10 provide important, interesting, and novel insights into solving this age-old riddle using a previously unexplored angle-autonomic manipulation. Acetylcholine was used to induce AF in 31 canines. In 12 of the animal studies, propafenone was administered. They then ablated the ganglionated plexi (GP). Before ablation, AF could still be induced despite administration of propafenone. After ablation, there was a consistent pattern of electrogram organization and atrial synchronization. In addition, subsequent administration of propafenone resulted in the inability to induce atrial tachyarrhythmia. There are several …