Athletic Training Students’ Mental Health Recognition and Referral Skills, Part 1: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Context The increased prevalence of mental health conditions and athletic training education’s heightened focus on behavioral and mental health necessitate an examination of teaching techniques for this material. This study explores the impact of virtual pedagogical strategies on athletic training students’ knowledge and confidence with mental health recognition and referral to help educators determine best practices for content delivery. Objective This study examined the effect of Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) training on students’ knowledge and confidence in mental health recognition and referral. The impact of group allocation (standardized patient [SP] encounters, case-based learning [CBL], and control) on these outcomes was also assessed. Design Randomized controllled trial portion from a sequential, explanatory mixed-methods design. Setting Online learning environment. Patients or Other Participants Convenience sample of 70 students (25 men, 44 women, 1 nonbinary; aged 23.38 ± 2.27 years) from Commission on Accreditation of Athletic Training Education-accredited graduate-level professional athletic training programs. Intervention(s) All participants completed MHFA training followed by either no intervention, an SP encounter, or CBL activity. Main Outcome Measure(s) Mental health recognition and referral skills as measured by an electronic knowledge assessment and self-reported confidence scale whose content validity were established by an expert panel. Results A mixed-model analysis of variance showed significant improvement from pretest to posttest for both knowledge and confidence [knowledge: F(1,67) = 70.31, P < .001; confidence: F(1,67) = 206.41, P < .001]. This relationship was similar among all 3 groups. No significant difference in knowledge or confidence was found between the control, SP, and CBL groups. Conclusions With the increased need to care for patients’ behavioral and mental health, professional athletic training programs and continuing education should consider incorporating MHFA training to improve content knowledge and confidence in skills. While no numerical difference between the groups was shown by this study, supplementation with simulation through CBL or SP encounters provides an opportunity for application specific to athletic training practice, which may help reinforce concepts and enhance clinical readiness.