Asymptotic Site-Index Curves, Fact or Artifact?

Abstract

In the absence of permanent sample plot data, site-index curves and equations showing the height/age relationship for a tree species growing on a given site have been derived using stem analysis and temporary sample plot data. Initially the guide-curve method using temporary sample plot data (Bruce and Schumacher 1950) was employed to produce anamorphic site-index curves. More recently mensurationists (e.g. Heger 1968, and Payandeh 1978) have used stem analysis data and various regression techniques to produce polymorphic curves. This study suggests that the asymptotic site-index curves (i.e. curves that tend to level off within the life of the stand) that have been produced for black spruce may be the result of using mensurational and sampling techniques in forests where site-index is correlated with age. Also the regression techniques commonly used to estimate the parameters in site-index equations do not allow for error in both the dependent variable (height) and an independent variable (site). As a consequence the site-index curves produced by these techniques are asymptotic whereas height estimates obtained from 40 black spruce permanent sample plots do not exhibit any strong asymptotic height properties for stands up to 180 years of age.