Association between shoulder coracoacromial arch morphology and anterior instability of the shoulder

Abstract

BackgroundGlenohumeral instability is a common condition of the shoulder. Glenoid bone loss and humeral head bone loss are well recognized as risk factors for recurrent instability. There are few studies in the literature that examine the role of coracoacromial arch anatomy in the pathogenesis of glenohumeral instability. Previous reports found an association between posterior acromial coverage (PAC) and posterior instability. We hypothesize that coracoacromial arch anatomy is related to anterior shoulder instability.MethodsIn this retrospective cohort study, 50 patients with unidirectional anterior shoulder instability were matched to a control group of 50 glenohumeral arthritis patients without any history of shoulder instability. Radiographic measurements of the coracoacromial arch anatomy were made: shoulder arch angle, scapular Y angle, anterior coracoid tilt (ACT), posterior acromial tilt, anterior acromial coverage angle, PAC angle, coracoid height, posterior acromial height, and critical shoulder angle were determined using standard lateral scapular and anteroposterior radiographs.ResultsLogistic regression analyses found a significant association between the presence of anterior instability and flatter coracoacromial arch angles (mean, 124.1°) vs. the arthritis control group (mean, 120.6°) (odds ratios [OR] = 1.113; 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.039-1.191; P = .002). There was a significant association between anterior instability and ACT (OR = 1.144; 95% CI = 1.053-1.243; P = .001), whereas a negative association was found between anterior instability and PAC (OR = 0.909; 95% CI = 0.853-0.969; P = .004) and posterior acromial tilt (OR = 0.878; 95% CI = 0.773-0.998; P = .046). Lower critical shoulder angle values were associated with the arthritis group (28.2° vs. 33.9°) (OR = 1.555; 95% CI = 1.202-2.012; P = .001).ConclusionsShoulder coracoacromial arch morphology may play a role in the stability of the shoulder joint and development of recurrent anterior instability. Shoulders with a decreased shoulder arch angle, a less contained and flatter coracoacromial arch and larger ACT, were associated with anterior instability. This study identifies the shoulder coracoacromial arch angle and anterior coracoid tile angles as risk factors for anterior shoulder instability. Our findings suggest that measuring these angles may help orthopedic surgeons understand the risk of anterior instability and analyze risk factors to improve clinical decision making.