Assimilation of hydrologic and hydrometeorological data into distributed hydrologic model: Effect of adjusting mean field bias in radar-based precipitation estimates

Abstract

This paper investigates the effect of adjusting the mean field bias (MFB) in radar-based precipitation data on analysis and prediction of streamflow and soil moisture in assimilating streamflow or streamflow and in situ soil moisture data into distributed hydrologic models. To evaluate the effect of adjusting the MFB under realistic as well as idealized conditions, both real-world and synthetic experiments are carried out for the Eldon Catchment on the border of Oklahoma and Arkansas in the US. In the synthetic experiment, the MFB is modeled as a stationary Markov chain process. The synthetic experiment showed that adjusting the MFB in the assimilation process significantly improves streamflow analysis when the initial conditions are known with reasonable certainty, and that assimilating soil moisture in addition to streamflow improves analysis of streamflow as well as soil moisture if the initial conditions are largely uncertain. Adjusting the MFB during the assimilation process noticeably improved streamflow analysis over ranges of the MFB and random noise in the precipitation data. On the other hand, increasing the MFB and random noise in the precipitation data tended to degrade soil moisture analysis due possibly to over-adjusting soil moisture to mitigate the precipitation error. The real-world experiment with one-year dataset showed that adjusting the MFB during the assimilation process helped capture the peak as well as volume of outlet flow analysis as well as prediction, and that additionally assimilating interior flow observations was necessary to improve analysis and prediction of peak flows at interior locations.