Assessment of Ventricular Septal Defect Size and Morphology by Three-Dimensional Transthoracic Echocardiography

Abstract

Morphologic description of ventricular septal defect (VSD) is mandatory before performing the newly developed transcatheter closure procedure. Inaccurate estimation of defect size has been reported using conventional two-dimensional (2D) transthoracic echocardiography (TTE). The aim of this study was to assess VSD morphology and size using three-dimensional (3D) TTE compared with 2D TTE and surgery. Forty-eight children aged 21.4±29.3months with isolated muscular (n=11 [22.9%]) and membranous (n=37 [77.1%]) VSDs were prospectively included. Three-dimensional images were acquired using full-volume single-beat mode. Minimal diameter, maximal diameter, and systolic and diastolic VSD areas were measured from 3D data sets using multiplanar reconstruction mode (QLAB 9). Maximal-to-minimal VSD diameter ratio was used to assess VSD geometry. Linear regression analysis and the Bland-Altman method were used to compare 3D measurements with 2D and surgical measurements in a subgroup of 15 patients who underwent surgical VSD closure. VSD 3D diameters and areas were measured in all patients (100%; 95% CI, 92.6%-100%). Maximal diameter was lower on 2D TTE compared with 3D TTE (7.3 vs 11.3mm, P<.0001). Mean bias was 4mm, with 95% of values ranging from -1.76 to 9.75mm. Correlation between 3D maximal diameter and surgical diameter was strong (r(2)=0.97, P<.0001), while correlation between maximal 2D diameter and surgical diameter was moderate (r(2)=0.63, P<.0001). VSDs had an oval shape when assessed by 3D TTE. Maximal-to-minimal diameter ratio assessed by 3D TTE was significantly higher in muscular VSDs compared with membranous VSDs (3.20±1.51 vs 2.13±1.28, respectively, P=.01). VSD area variation throughout the cardiac cycle was 32% and was higher in muscular compared with membranous VSDs (49% vs 26%, P=.0001). Three-dimensional TTE allows better VSD morphologic and maximal diameter assessment compared with 2D TTE. VSD shape and its changes during the cardiac cycle can be visually and quantitatively displayed. Three-dimensional echocardiography may thus be particularly useful before and during percutaneous VSD closure.