Assessment of the Suitability of Extractants for Predicting Plant Available Arsenic in Some Tropical Rice Growing Inceptisols of Eastern India

Abstract

ABSTRACT The complex behavior of arsenic (As) in soil in conjunction to crop mediated transfer through the food chain necessitates a thorough evaluation of its phyto-availability. In this pretext, the present experiment has been conducted to determine the best chemical extractant for plant available As under the As-prone, rice-dominant agro-ecosystems of Gangetic West Bengal, India. Based on the tube-well arsenic data (JPOA, UNICEF), surface soil samples from high, medium, low and uncontaminated As sites have been collected. A pot study with rice cv. IR-36, exposed to varying levels of As (0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3 and 0.4 mg L−1) was conducted. Ten chemical extractants were used in this study. The As extraction pattern followed the pattern of (HCl+H2SO4)>; (NH4-oxalate+Ascorbic acid)>; (Malic+Citric)> NaOH> KH2PO4> NaHCO3>; (H2O2+HNO3)> NH4F> NH4Cl> NH4OAc. On the 85th day after sowing, the rice plants were harvested keeping in mind that the maximum uptakes of heavy metals like As occurs during the peak vegetative growth (panicle initiation) stage. The soil As correlated with rice dry matter As accumulation as: NH4-oxalate+ascorbic acid (r = 0.729**)> NH4Cl (r = 0.698**)> H2O2+HNO3 (r = 0.697**)> NH4F (r = 0.693**)>Malic+Citric (r = 0.666**)> KH2PO4 (r = 0.615**)> HCl+H2SO4 (r = 0.608**)> NaOH (r = 0.589**)> NaHCO3 (r = 0.571**)> NH4OAc (r = 0.533*). Statistical analyses through correlation sum and stepwise multiple regression modeling revealed that NH4-oxalate+ascorbic acid had the best relationship with all other extractants, As fractions and soil physicochemical characters and therefore emerged as the best suited extractant of As for the wide-scale experimental locations under rice cultivation system.