Assessment of semi-empirical molecular orbital calculations for describing magnetic interactions

Abstract

We report a thorough comparison between the spin-unrestricted semi-empirical molecular orbital (SE-UMO) and density functional theory (UDFT) calculations for a variety of π-conjugated diradical molecules which exhibit through-bond magnetic exchange interactions. The spin-unrestricted neglect of diatomic differential overlap (NDDO)-based methods (UPM6 and UrPM6) and self-consistent charge density functional tight-biding (UDFTB) are examined. The UCAM-B3LYP method is used as a representative of UDFT. We have found that NDDO-based and UDFTB methods give different performances with respect to the results of UCAM-B3LYP. The degree of diradical character in the target systems decreases in the order of UPM6>UrPM6≈UCAM-B3LYP>UDFTB. The conventional UPM6 and UDFTB calculations tend to overestimate and underestimate the diradical character, respectively, whereas UrPM6 is able to provide much the same results as UCAM-B3LYP. This is convincing evidence that UrPM6 will be useful for in silico screening of materials science at much lower computational cost.