Assessment of RANS turbulence models on predicting supercritical heat transfer in highly buoyant horizontal flows

Abstract

This paper rigorously validates the RANS models against the DNS on predicting turbulent flow and heat transfer of highly buoyant horizontal supercritical fluids. The low-Reynolds number turbulence models of RNG, AKN, V2F and ( k − ω ) SST that are recommended in literature are selected. Also, the LS model demonstrating good performance in some in-house CFD codes has been reimplemented via User-Defined Functions (UDFs) and examined for supercritical simulations, in particular with strong buoyancy effects. The results indicated that the AKN model works best among the tested models on the reproductions of some bulk parameters that are of interest (such as wall temperature, Nusselt number and skin friction coefficient) and the distortions of the turbulent velocity profile caused by the strong buoyancy, closely followed by the V2F model. The UDFs implemented LS model exhibits much better performances than the originally incorporated version in FLUENT, which is attributed to the more proper model implementation that leads to better treatments on the fluid flow and heat transfer, especially in the near-wall regions. Regarding the reproductions on the turbulence kinetic energy generations under the studied conditions, the RANS models are unable to give satisfactory results, the simulated suppression in the top half is more drastic. Similar to the vertical supercritical fluids, with quite high-strength buoyancy, the heat transfer recovers around the horizontal pipe top wall but the RANS models' response to the “recovery” is poor. The model performance on reproducing the turbulent statistics is closely related to the implementation of the vital structural parameters.