Assessment of Gaussian-4 theory for the computation of enthalpies of formation of large organic molecules

Abstract

Gas-phase enthalpies of formation of 122 relatively large organic molecules with up to 15 non-hydrogen atoms have been calculated at the Gaussian-4 (G4) level of theory using the atomization reaction procedure. The calculated values were compared with experimental data published mainly last years. Particular attention has been given to nitro compounds and nitrogen, oxygen, and sulfur containing heterocyclic compounds. The expected accumulation of systematic errors as the molecular size increases was not observed with increasing the number of non-hydrogen atoms from 6 to 15. The largest mean absolute deviation between experimental and G4 enthalpies of formation, 10.7 kJ/mol, was revealed for nitro compounds. All theoretical values for nitro compounds were underestimated by 5–15 kJ/mol. The best agreement with experiment with mean absolute deviation of 4.5 kJ/mol was observed for compounds which types were widely presented in the original test set of G4 method. The mean absolute deviations for nitrogen heterocycles (6.8 kJ/mol) and oxygen and sulfur heterocycles (9.1 kJ/mol) are noticeably larger. Experimental enthalpies of formation of four compounds (N,N-dinitromethanamine, 2,3,5,6-tetrachloronitrobenzene, 2-methyl-2H-tetrazole, and proline) were suggested to be unreliable from comparison with the G4 values calculated from atomization energies and isodesmic reactions.