Assessment of early attrition using an ordinary flatbed scanner

Abstract

The aim of this study was to assess a two-dimensional method to monitor occlusal tooth wear quantitatively using a commercially available ordinary flatbed scanner. Materials and methodsA flatbed scanner, measuring software and gypsum casts were used. In Part I, two observers (A and B) independently traced scans of marked wear facets of ten sets of casts in two sessions (test and retest). In Part II, three other sets of casts were duplicated and two observers (C and D) marked wear facets and traced the scanned images independently. Intra- and inter-observer agreement was determined comparing measured values (mm2) in paired T-tests. Duplicate measurement errors (DME) were calculated. ResultsIn Part I the test and retest values (10 casts, 218 teeth) of observer A and B did not differ significantly (A: p=0.289; B: p=0.666); correlation coefficients were 0.998 (A) and 0.999 (B). “Tracing wear facets” showed a DME of 0.30mm2 for observer A and 0.15mm2 for observer B. In Part II, assessment of 70 teeth resulted in correlation coefficients of 0.994 for observer C and 0.997 for observer D; no differences between test and retest values were found for C (p=0.061), although D differed significantly (p=0.000). The DME for “marking and tracing wear facets” was 0.39mm2 (C) and 0.27mm2 (D). DME for inter-observer agreement were 0.45mm2 (test) and 0.42mm2 (re-test). Conclusion and clinical relevanceWe conclude that marking and tracing of occlusal wear facets to assess occlusal tooth wear quantitatively can be done accurately and reproducibly.