Assessment of Different Satellite Image-Derived Drought Indices over the Contiguous United States: A Comparison in Different Climates, Vegetation Cover Types, and Soil Layers

Abstract

Agricultural drought assessment is based on soil moisture deficit during the plant-growing season. The available long-term in situ soil moisture data can be used to evaluate the drought indices’ performance. Drought indices have different sensitivities to various climates and vegetation cover types. Moreover, little research has been carried out on the sensitivity to soil moisture in specific soil layers. Comparing the performance of drought indices in different environments enables us to use and construct an effective drought index for drought delineation. We used soil moisture data from 2000 to 2021 to compare the performance of satellite image-derived drought indices (VCI, NLSWI, TCI, VHI, and NVSWI) in different climates, vegetation cover types, and soil layers over the Contiguous United States at monthly intervals and a 1000 m spatial resolution. The performances of drought indices based on vegetation status showed little differences in the different soil layers. In contrast, drought indices based on single-temperature conditions performed better in the 0–20 cm soil layer than in the deeper soil layer. The integrated index might not improve the correlation in all soil layers compared with single-condition indices under some environments. In general, while the optimal drought index might vary in different environments, the VHI performed most efficiently in most cases. This research has the potential to improve our understanding of drought monitoring in large regions with different climates, vegetation cover types, and soil layers.