Assessing zygomatic shape and size for estimating sex and ancestry in a South African sample

Abstract

Unidentified, decomposed and skeletonised human remains are frequently found in South Africa, therefore, standardised, reliable and relevant sex and ancestry estimation methods are required for forensic identification. This study assessed sex and ancestral variation in zygomatic size and shape in a South African population using geometric morphometric analyses. The zygoma of 158 South African individuals were sampled. Eight zygomatic landmarks were captured in 3-dimensions using a Microscribe G2 digitiser and assessed using procrustean geometric morphometrics. Shape and size differences were analysed using multivariate linear regression, discriminant function and canonical variate analyses. Males had significantly larger zygomas than females. Significant shape variation was found between ancestral groups. Bantu-speaking and Mixed ancestry individuals had narrower, shorter and more anteriorly projecting orbital margins, whilst Europeans had vertically elongated and receded orbital margins. European ancestral groups were most discernible from Bantu-speakers and Mixed ancestral groups. Ancestry estimation accuracies improved when ancestry was aggregated with sex. Pairwise ancestry-linked comparisons in females were as follows; Bantu-speakers (76%) from Europeans (72%), Bantu-speakers (71%) from Mixed ancestry (59%) and European (72%) from Mixed ancestry (63%). Similarly, ancestry-linked comparisons in males were as follows; Bantu-speakers (77%) from Europeans (81%), Bantu-speakers (53%) from Mixed ancestry (59%) and European (72%) from Mixed ancestry (82%). Size differences are putatively linked to variations in hormone-regulated growth and muscular robusticity between males and females. Shape variations between ancestral groups are likely attributable to the heterogenous genetic and ancestral origins of the South African population. It is challenging to distinguish between South Africa Bantu speakers and Mixed ancestry people due to Mixed ancestry individuals having variable genetic contributions from Khoesan, Bantu-speakers, Europeans and Asians. Bantu-speaking and Mixed ancestry people had zygomatic morphologies consistent with historical thermoregulatory adaptations to sub-Saharan climates, reported in African-descendants. Zygomatic morphology in European descendants suggests ancestral origins from colder climatic regions. This study demonstrated the utility of the zygoma in distinguishing between ancestral groups in South Africa, but further research is required to develop population-specific standards to distinguish between South African populations with shared African ancestry. The zygoma shows a promising ability to estimate sex and ancestry in South Africans, suggesting population specific standards for this bone may be of forensic interest.