Assessing the watershed-scale effects of tillage management on surface runoff and sediment loss using a Curve Number-precipitation relationship based approach

Abstract

Poor soil management limits the soil functions of water infiltration and storage and enhances water and soil losses. Adoption of improved soil management practices is thus vital to protecting agricultural soils amid recurring droughts and declining water availability. Although the benefits of adopting soil health promoting practices such as no-tillage (NT) have been extensively investigated at field scale, studies quantifying the watershed-scale impacts of such practices are lacking. This study aims to address this gap by quantifying soil and water conservation benefits of adopting NT over conventional tillage (CT) on all croplands in the Brushy Creek Watershed in the Texas Blackland Prairies using the Agricultural Policy/Environmental eXtender (APEX) model. Most hydrologic and water quality models often fall short in accurately simulating the effects of management practices since they are not capable of simulating changes in soil and hydrologic properties that result from changes in soil management. This study proposed a novel framework to translate field-scale rainfall and runoff relationships into a watershed-scale parameterization tool that can be used for any agricultural watershed where measured rainfall and runoff data are available. Curve Number–Precipitation (CN-P) relationships were first defined based on field observations of rainfall and runoff from paired CT and NT fields. The CT and NT APEX models were then trained to follow the defined CN-P relationships to reflect the associated changes in hydrologic properties. Changing management from CT to NT on all croplands in the study watershed (i.e., in 35% of the watershed area) resulted in a 25% (38 mm year−1) reduction in average annual runoff and a 57% (1.13 t ha -1year−1) reduction in average annual sediment loss at the outlet of the watershed. The reduction in sediment loss from individual subareas with NT management was found to be sensitive to subarea physical properties such as slope and channel depth to width ratio, but the reduction in runoff was not sensitive to those properties. Results from this study are useful to natural resource conservationists and watershed managers in effectively implementing improved soil management practices.