Assessing temporal response to biomass removal: A framework for investigating evolving constraints on boreal stand development

Abstract

Impacts of harvest intensity and soil disturbance on site productivity are likely to vary with stand development stage and interactive processes related to ecosystem function. On upland boreal sites, stand productivity may initially be constrained by microclimatic conditions. However, increasing nutrient demands and overstory light interception associated with canopy development may place progressively greater emphasis on nutrient availability, profile water storage capacity and asymmetric competition. We illustrate these effects using 20-yr post-harvest data from fourteen jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) and black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill.) BSP) Long-term Soil Productivity (LTSP) installations in northern Ontario.Initial growth and ten-year survival were as great or greater without forest floors (NFF), but by year 15 dominant height increments were usually greater with intact forest floors (FF). Growing season frost occurrence and high vapor pressure deficits occurred more frequently with FF than NFF treatments during the initial stand establishment phase. Similarly, mean growing season soil temperatures were 2-5˚C warmer with NFF during this phase, with stand Leaf Area Index (LAI) values < 0.5. During the following Accelerated Growth phase, treatment differences in microclimate dissipated as LAI increased. Foliar N concentrations and N:P ratios, and soil net N mineralization were usually greater from an early age with FF, and often declined as canopy closure approached. Likewise, modelled site-level constraints related to soil water availability increased with stand development, peaking at LAI values associated with the stem exclusion stage. Placing post-harvest response (i.e., impacts of harvest intensity) in the context of relationships among stand structural development, changes in microclimate, and resource supply and demand should provide greater insights into longer-term effects of establishment practices.