Assessing medical students' awareness of and sensitivity to diverse health beliefs using a standardized patient station.

Abstract

To assess students' performances on a health-beliefs communication OSCE station to determine whether there were differences in cultural competence based on the students' ethnic backgrounds. A total of 71 students completed a health-beliefs communication OSCE station in which they were required to address the health beliefs and cultural concerns of a standardized patient (SP) portraying an African American woman with diabetes. The SPs rated students' performances on a ten-item interview assessment checklist. Scores on the station were standardized within SPs to adjust for differences in their use of the rating scale. A factor analysis was performed to determine conceptual constructs on the interview assessment checklist. Subscale means were computed for each student. T-tests of these subscale scores were conducted to investigate gender and ethnic differences between subgroups of students. The underrepresented minority (URM) students (five African Americans and three Mexican Americans) were compared with all other students, and the white students were compared with all others. To assess the magnitudes of the differences between subgroups, effect sizes (ES(m)) were computed for means comparisons. Factor analysis formed two factors: Disease Beliefs and Management, and Cultural Concerns. Two remaining items loaded on a third factor that had reliability too low to support further analysis. Meaningful differences were found in cultural sensitivity based on students' ethnic backgrounds. The URM students performed better than did all other students in addressing the patient's concerns about altering culturally-based dietary behaviors for diabetes self-care [URM students' mean standardized score (SD) = 0.42 (0.15); all others = -0.01 (0.67); ES(m) = 1.05]. White students performed better than did all other students in assessing the patient's concerns about using insulin to control her blood sugar levels [white students' mean standardized score (SD) = 0.13 (0.40); all others = -0.10 (0.64); ES(m) = 0.4]. Cultural competency deficits and differences were measurable using a health-beliefs communications station, and these differences were meaningful enough to warrant faculty discussion and research about how to ensure that students master this competency.