Assessing measurable adverse changes to benthic invertebrate communities based on site-specific sediment toxicity testing and community data at the Anniston, Alabama PCB site

Abstract

ABSTRACTLaboratory toxicity tests were conducted for polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB)-containing sediment from Choccolocco Creek at the Anniston PCB Site. The objective of this investigation was to develop a site-specific PCB concentration–response relationship for invertebrate test organisms. Test results from reference locations were used to develop background-adjusted 10% (EC10*) and 20% (EC20*) effect concentrations for a range of survival, growth, and reproduction endpoints. The EC20* values ranged from 4.43 to 114 milligrams of PCBs per kilogram (mg/kg) of sediment on a dry weight basis for reproductive endpoints, 28 to 67.7 mg/kg sediment for growth, and 123 to 165 mg/kg sediment for survival. The aggregate EC20* response range for endpoints that demonstrated good test performance with reasonable ranges in control variability (<20%) and reference sample responses was 14.3 to 165 mg/kg. The PCB concentrations in sediments for a majority of the Site rarely exceed even the lowest of these thresholds. Given the protective process used to develop these thresholds, there is a high level of confidence that benthic communities are not impacted. This finding is supported by direct measurements of the benthic communities that have been living and reproducing on the Site.