Assessing Kinematic Variables in Short-Track Speed Skating Helmets: A Comparative Study between Traditional Rigid Foam and Anti-Rotation Designs

Abstract

Purpose: Short-track speed skating results in high-energy crashes with an elevated risk of head injury. The goal of this study was to evaluate the resulting kinematics of an anti-rotation helmet technology for speed skating. Methods: Two traditional rigid foam speed-skating helmets (BT and ST) were compared with one anti-rotation speed skating helmet (MIPS). Each helmet was impacted with a pneumatic device across three locations. The resulting linear or rotational accelerations (PLA or PRA) and rotational velocities (PRV) were measured with accelerometers placed on a Hybrid III head form. Additionally, the head impact criterion (HIC) was calculated from accelerations and the brain injury criterion (BrIC) was obtained from rotational velocities. Results: MIPS showed significantly higher values of accelerations (PLA = 111.24 ± 9.21 g and PRA = 8759.11 ± 2601.81 rad/s2) compared with the other helmets at all three impact locations (p < 0.01, ES = 3.00 to 4.11). However, velocities were lowest, but not significantly different, for the MIPS helmet (25.77 ± 1.43 rad/s). Furthermore, all resulting kinematics except peak linear accelerations were significantly different across impact locations. Conclusion: Helmet designs specific to the collision characteristics of speed skating may still be lacking, but would decrease the risk of sport-related concussions.