Assessing host specificity of a classical biological control agent against western corn rootworm with a recently developed testing protocol

Abstract

Celatoria compressa (Wulp) (Diptera: Tachinidae), a parasitoid of adult chrysomelid beetles in the subtribe Diabroticina in North America, has been selected as a candidate for classical biological control of the alien invader, Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae: Galerucinae), into Europe. We conducted host specificity testing to evaluate the fundamental host range of C. compressa and potential risks to native European coleopteran species. Nine potential non-target beetles were tested for host selection with D. v. virgifera in no-choice tests, sequential no-choice tests, choice tests and sequential choice tests in small experimental arenas in a quarantine laboratory. The nine representative non-target species were selected for experimentation based on (1) ecological host range information of C. compressa, (2) ecological similarities to D. v. virgifera, (3) close phylogenetic/taxonomic relationships, (4) safeguard considerations, (5) morphological similarities, geographical distributions, overlap of temporal occurrences with D. v. virgifera and C. compressa, and (6) accessibility and availability. Of the potential nine non-target hosts tested, gravid C. compressa only parasitized a few red pumpkin beetles, Aulacophora foveicollis (Chrysomelidae: Galerucinae), regardless of the presence or absence of D. v. virgifera. However, C. compressa significantly preferred D. v. virgifera (44.6% parasitized) over A. foveicollis (2.7%) in choice tests. Of the 1110 A. foveicollis tested among all experiment types, only 23 were parasitized and only one C. compressa successfully developed from the parasitism, demonstrating that A. foveicollis is a poor host. In conclusion, C. compressa has a fundamental host range restricted to the subtribes Diabroticina and Aulacophorina, and would therefore be unlikely to have a direct impact on indigenous species in Europe.