Assessing and modeling diurnal temperature buffering and evapotranspiration dynamics in forest restoration using ECOSTRESS thermal imaging

Abstract

Restoration of temperate forests alters the diurnal dynamics of land surface temperature (LST) and evapotranspiration (ET) through increases in biomass, diversity, and complexity. The ECOsystem Spaceborne Thermal Radiometer Experiment on Space Station (ECOSTRESS) is the first space-based thermal imaging instrument that allows for a study of diurnal LST and ET dynamics at a moderate spatial resolution (70 × 70 m).We quantified, compared, and modeled the LST and ET dynamics of two groups of forest restoration sites (43 sites in total, between 2 and 75 ha) in Southern Ontario, Canada that were initially restored from mainly agriculture between 2007 and 2019. We included all useable LST (n = 29) and ET (n = 9) ECOSTRESS image products from a full growing season in 2020 (June 1st to September 30th). Forest restoration sites were compared by age and against agriculture (pre-restoration state), mature forest (post-restoration state), and suburban residential sites (competing land use).The ability of forest restoration sites to buffer temperatures was highest in the afternoon, around 14:00 local time (EDT). As predicted, restoration sites were significantly cooler (x̄ 4.4–7.4 °C) than residential and agricultural areas and significantly warmer (x̄1.6–2.9 °C) compared to mature reference forest sites at both groups of sites. Relative diurnal (24-h) LST variability of forest and restoration sites was also significantly lower (0.9–2.9 °C) compared to agriculture and residential sites (3.3–5.2 °C). Daytime LST decreased significantly by 0.1 °C (3.1%), per year since restoration for one of the groups of sites relative to nearby mature reference forest sites as per a linear mixed effects regression model. It would take these sites ~30 years to reach the same buffering as mature forests. In characterizing ET dynamics of a subset of sites, we found that more recently restored sites had a statistically significant higher overall ET than older ones and that daytime relative instantaneous ET decreased with years since restoration. The variation explained by the ET model was however low.Our study provides insights into how diurnal forest ecosystem energy conversion and storage dynamics changes over time after restoration. These diurnal thermal dynamics impact wildlife habitat as well as human wellbeing. The change in thermal buffering over time could be used to assess the pace and trajectory of restoration by managers. The thermal buffering provided by restored forest can also be quantified as an ecosystem service. As such, the study demonstrates the utility and also limitations of novel thermal remote sensing methods, using free and publicly available imagery from ECOSTRESS.