Aryl Nitrenium and Oxenium Ions with Unusual High-Spin π,π* Ground States: Exploiting (Anti)Aromaticity.

Abstract

Nitrenium and oxenium ions are important reactive intermediates in synthetic and biological processes, and their ground electronic configurations are of great interest due to having distinct reactivities and properties. In general, the closed-shell singlet state of these intermediates usually react as electrophiles, while reactions of the triplet states of these ions react like typical diradicals (e.g., H atom abstractions). Nonsubstituted phenyl nitrenium ions (Ph-NH+) and phenyl oxenium ions (Ph-O+) have closed-shell singlet ground states with large singlet-triplet gaps resulting from a strong break in the degeneracy of the p orbitals on the formal nitrenium/oxenium center. Remarkably, we find computationally (CBS-QB3 and G4MP2) that azulenyl nitrenium and oxenium ions can have triplet ground states depending upon the attachment position on the azulene core. For instance, CBS-QB3 predicts that 1-azulenyl nitrenium ion and 1-azulenyl oxenium ion are singlet ground-state species with considerable singlet-triplet gaps of -47 and -45 kcal/mol to the lowest-energy triplet state, respectively. In contrast, 6-azulenyl nitrenium ion and 6-azulenyl oxenium ion have triplet ground states with a singlet-triplet gap of +7 and +10 kcal/mol, respectively. Moreover, the triplet states are π,π* states, rather than the typical n,π* states seen for many aryl nitrenium or oxenium ions. This dramatic switch in favored electronic states can be ascribed to changes in ring aromaticity/antiaromaticity, with the switch from ground-state singlet ions to triplet-favored ions resulting from both a destabilized singlet state (Hückel antiaromatic) and a stabilized triplet (Baird aromatic) state. Density functional theory (UB3LYP/6-31+G(d,p)) was used to determine substituent effects on the singlet-triplet energy gap for azulenyl nitrenium and oxenium ions, and we find that the unusual ground triplet states can be further tuned by employing electron-donating or -withdrawing groups on the azulene ring. This work demonstrates that azulenyl nitrenium and oxenium ions can have triplet π,π* ground states and provides a simple recipe for making ionic intermediates with distinct electronic configurations and consequent prediction of unique reactivity and magnetic properties from these species.