“Are the genre and the Geschlecht one and the same number?” An inquiry into Alfred Clebsch's Geschlecht

Abstract

This article is aimed at throwing new light on the history of the notion of genus, whose paternity is usually attributed to Bernhard Riemann while its original name Geschlecht is often credited to Alfred Clebsch. By comparing the approaches of the two mathematicians, we show that Clebsch's act of naming was rooted in a projective geometric reinterpretation of Riemann's research, and that his Geschlecht was actually a different notion than that of Riemann. We also prove that until the beginning of the 1880s, mathematicians clearly distinguished between the notions of Clebsch and Riemann, the former being mainly associated with algebraic curves, and the latter with surfaces and Riemann surfaces. In the concluding remarks, we discuss the historiographic issues raised by the use of phrases like “the genus of a Riemann surface”—which began to appear in some works of Felix Klein at the very end of the 1870s—to describe Riemann's original research.