Are northern bobwhites an umbrella species for open‐land birds in Ohio?

Abstract

AbstractBirds that inhabit open lands such as grasslands and shrublands are rapidly declining across North America. A common practice for multi‐species management is to focus on umbrella species whose habitat requirements overlap with several other species. We evaluated whether the northern bobwhite (Colinus virginianus; bobwhite) could serve as an umbrella species for open‐land birds in Ohio, USA. We related landscape metrics to abundance patterns and assessed whether bobwhite occupancy positively predicts presence of open‐land birds. We combined bird survey data from the second Ohio Breeding Bird Atlas (2006–2011) with land cover data from the 2011 National Land Cover Database (Homer et al. 2015) to construct single‐season N‐mixture models to identify landscape metrics that influence bobwhite abundance. Bobwhite abundance was positively predicted by forest cohesion, percent agriculture, percent barren, and percent grassland. Of the 34 focal species, bobwhites were a significant positive predictor for 12, and a significant negative predictor for 10. The model with only bobwhite occupancy probability as a predictor was the best supported model for only willow flycatcher (Empidonax traillii). These results suggest that bobwhite land cover type requirements are too specialized to meet the needs of broader species guilds, instead affording protection for a narrower range of individual species that share specific habitat requirements with bobwhites. Management for bobwhites may still be able to promote co‐occurrence for declining species across multiple guilds by identifying locations where focused management can create more suitable conditions for species with positive co‐occurrence.