Are knee savers and knee pads a viable intervention to reduce lower extremity musculoskeletal disorder risk in residential roofers?

Abstract

One factor commonly associated with musculoskeletal disorder risk is extreme postures. To lessen this risk, extreme postures should be reduced using proactive and prevention-focused methods. The effect of combinations of two interventions, knee pads and knee savers, on lower extremity kinematics during deep or near full flexion kneeling on differently sloped surfaces was analyzed. Nine male subjects were requested to keep a typical resting posture while kneeling on a sloped roofing simulator with and without knee pads and knee savers. Three-dimensional peak knee kinematics were recording using a motion capture system. The kinematic data were analyzed with a two-way—4(intervention) X 3(slope)—repeated measure analysis of variance (ANOVA). It was observed that knee pads did not alter lower extremity kinematics in a way that may reduce musculoskeletal injury risk, but they do provide comfort. Knee savers did statistically significantly reduce peak lower extremity kinematics, however these changes were small and it is uncertain if the changes will reduce musculoskeletal injury risk. This study has provided initial data that supports the use of knee savers as a potential intervention to reduce musculoskeletal disorder risk due to lower extremity joint angles on a sloped surface, nonetheless, further testing involving other musculoskeletal disorder risk factors is needed prior to a conclusive recommendation.