Are inert glasses really inert?

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate the degradation of inert glass fillers which are commonly used in conventional resin-based composites to provide radiopacity, reduce the polymerization shrinkage and improve the mechanical properties. 75mg of five different glass powders (1µm) was immersed separately into 50mL of acetic acid (pH 4) and tris buffer (pH 7.4) for up to 4 weeks. At each time point the glass powder was filtered and dried for characterization using ATR-FTIR and XRD to assess the degradation behavior and crystallization. ICP-OES, ISE and pH measurements were performed on the supernatant solutions to monitor the pH and ion release. Although FTIR and XRD analysis showed no significant glass degradation or crystallization upon immersion, there was a substantial release of ions from the inert fillers, especially from BABFG and CDL. Barium release for these fillers were 270 and 165ppm respectively. G018-373 glass presented the lowest ion release followed by GM27884 and BABG. The ion release was more pronounced in acidic conditions compared to neutral conditions apart from the fluoride release. Inert glasses are not as inert as previously thought. This may result in leaching of ions, potentially causing toxicity, reduction in mechanical properties, increased wear and subsequent failure of the composite material. The ions released from the inert glass may interfere with other glass fillers such as bioactive glass fillers, inhibiting degradation of the bioactive glass, beneficial ion release from the bioactive glass, pH neutralization and apatite formation.