Architecting a chunk-based memory race recorder in modern CMPs

Abstract

Prior work on HW support for memory race recording piggybacks time stamps on coherence messages and logs the outcome of memory races using point-to-point or chunk-based approaches. These memory race recorder (MRR) techniques are effective, but they require modifications to the cache coherence protocol that can hurt performance. In addition, prior work has mostly focused on directory coherence and considered only CMP systems with single-level cache hierarchies. Most modern CMP systems shipped today, however, implement snoop coherence and feature multilevel cache hierarchies. To be practical, a MRR must target CMPs with multilevel caches, mitigate the coherence overhead due to piggybacking, and emphasize on replay speed to broaden applicability of deterministic replay. This paper contributes three new solutions for making chunk-based MRR practical for modern CMPs. We show that MRR interactions with a cache hierarchy can degrade performance and present a novel mechanism that mitigates this degradation. We propose new mechanisms for snoop-based caches that eliminate coherence traffic overhead due to piggybacking. We finally propose new techniques for improving replay speed and introduce a novel framework for evaluating the replay speed potential of MRR designs.