Application of autonomic nervous function evaluation to job stress screening

Abstract

The present study focuses on the evaluation of autonomic nervous function, which is increasingly being used as an objective measure of fatigue state. It has recently been reported that autonomic nervous activity, which is expressed as total heart rate variability (HRV) power, is associated with, and can be used as an objective measure of, mental and physical fatigue. Total HRV power (log (LF + HF)) has been shown to decline with ageing, and thus cannot be utilized as a fatigue index in populations with a different age composition. In the present study, we devised standard scores (deviation value) for autonomic nervous activity corrected for individual age calculated from the distribution of such activity in individual age cohorts. This allowed us to accurately evaluate an individual's autonomic nervous activity, even when that individual was part of a group with members of different ages. Standard scores were quantified using autonomic nervous function data gathered from 1,969 healthy individuals (age range 20–77 years).The efficacy of this method in mental health screening was investigated by evaluating both autonomic nervous function and subjective levels of fatigue among corporate workers. Based on results from the Brief Job Stress Questionnaire recommended by the research team of the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, 103 participants were divided into two groups (a high-stress group [n = 17] and a non–high-stress group [n = 86]). Visual analog scale (VAS) scores for all fatigue-related symptoms were significantly higher among the high-stress than among the non–high-stress group (p < 0.01).The mean standard score for autonomic nervous activity was 56.3 for the non–high-stress group. The score for the high-stress group was significantly lower, at 47.9 (p < 0.01), indicating that autonomic nervous function was reduced among participants who experienced high stress. According to an analysis of raw and standard scores in each domain, autonomic nervous activity did not significantly correlate with stress-causing factors (e.g., overwork) or other factors affecting stress responses (e.g., support from supervisors and colleagues), but did exhibit a significant positive correlation with physical and mental responses to stress (r = 0.334, p < 0.01). Lower raw scores for mental and physical responses to stress represent stronger subjective symptoms. Moreover, greater stress responses were found to be associated with lower standard scores for autonomic nervous activity.In terms of fatigue-related symptoms rated using the VAS, autonomic nervous activity negatively correlated with mental stress, physical stress, fatigue/malaise, depressed mood, anxiety/fear, tension, irritation/anger, cognitive decline, and muscle/joint/general pain, and positively correlated with motivation/vitality. Reduced autonomic nervous activity was observed with high stress, confirming that standard scores for autonomic nervous activity are associated with mental and physical responses to stress and subjective fatigue-related symptoms.These results indicate that the evaluation of autonomic nervous activity using standard scores (deviation value) is a useful tool for the objective measurement of fatigue state, even in groups with members of different ages, and can be applied as a useful objective health index to evaluate industrial fatigue.