Application of a range of turbulence energy models to the determination of M4 tidal current profiles

Abstract

A fully nonlinear, three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of the Irish Sea, using a range of turbulence energy sub-models, is used to examine the influence of the turbulence closure method upon the vertical variation of the current profile of the fundamental and higher harmonics of the tide in the region. Computed tidal current profiles are compared with previous calculations using a spectral model with eddy viscosity related to the flow field. The model has a sufficiently fine grid to resolve the advection terms, in particular the advection of turbulence and momentum. Calculations show that the advection of turbulence energy does not have a significant influence upon the current profile of either the fundamental or higher harmonic of the tide, although the advection of momentum is important in the region of headlands. The simplification of the advective terms by only including them in their vertically integrated form does not appear to make a significant difference to current profiles, but does reduce the computational effort by a significant amount. Computed current profiles both for the fundamental and the higher harmonic determined with a prognostic equation for turbulence and an algebraic mixing length formula, are as accurate as those determined with a two prognostic equation model (the so called q 2– q 2 l model), provided the mixing length is specified correctly. A simple, flow-dependent eddy viscosity with a parabolic variation of viscosity also performs equally well.