Apparent predation of juvenile coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) by prickly sculpins (Cottus asper) is an artefact of trapping methodology

Abstract

Freshwater sculpins often inhabit the same waterways as juvenile salmonids and may impact the survival of juvenile salmonids through predation on early life-history stages. In the present study, the stomach contents of 2302 individual Cottus asper, a freshwater sculpin, collected from Auke Lake, Alaska, were examined during the boreal summer of 2000 to determine if C. asper are important natural predators of juvenile coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch), and to explore possible trap bias of gear used in preliminary diet studies. The diet of sculpins collected in confining traps was compared with the diet of sculpins collected in nets. Significant predation on pre-smolt coho salmon by trapped sculpins, but none by netted sculpins, was observed. This result provides strong evidence of trap bias in the observed diet of C. asper. The remainder of the diet of trapped sculpins also differed significantly from that of netted sculpins. Significantly more trapped sculpins had eaten plant material and fish, whereas significantly more netted sculpins had consumed molluscs. Finally, sculpin diet was correlated with sculpin size, which may influence predation on other salmonid life-stages. These results expand our understanding of prickly sculpin diet and show that they are not important predators of juvenile coho salmon. These findings also demonstrate the importance of assessing the potential bias of collection gear and sampling techniques.