Ants offset bottom-up control of spiders in Amazonian savanna trees

Abstract

Community trophic structure is shaped by concurrent bottom-up (resources) and top-down effects (predators), but the extent to which they interact remains uncertain. The Exploitation Ecosystems Hypothesis predicts that predators should offset increases in herbivore abundance with plant productivity, which is supported by data. However, the extent to which interactions within trophic levels (e.g. competition, intraguild predation) have similar effects is less clear. Ants and spiders are abundant in vegetation and consume similar arthropod prey (occasionally each other) and plant exudates, with ants generally showing competitive dominance over spiders. We tested whether ants could shape the trophic structure of tree-dwelling macroarthropod communities by offsetting increases in spider abundance with insect prey. We performed three surveys of the macroarthropod community of 97 trees from two sites in the savanna of Northern Amazonia. Together, ants and spiders represented 74% of the sampled individuals per tree. Insect prey abundance increased with tree crown volume and crown flower cover, consistent with bottom-up limitation. Likewise, both ants and spiders increased with insect prey abundance, with ant abundance also varying with tree species, suggesting reliance on both animal and plant resources. However, as predicted, the positive relationship between spider abundance and insect prey abundance disappeared as ant abundance increased. Our results suggest that agonistic interactions within trophic levels can strongly shape community structure and size by modifying bottom-up effects as much as interactions across trophic levels.