Analyzing sources of uncertainty in terrestrial organic carbon isotope data: A case study across the K-Pg boundary in Montana, USA

Abstract

The Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary (KPB) in the Hell Creek area of Montana is recognized in several places by an iridium anomaly, which is typically identified at or very near the lithological contact between the Hell Creek Formation and the Tullock Member of the Fort Union Formation. Previous work in the area has argued that organic carbon isotope (δ13Corg) excursions can be used for chemostratigraphic correlation within these continental depositional environments, most importantly for the identification of the KPB where impact evidence is unavailable. However, it is unclear how modern surficial weathering affects δ13Corg values, particularly in terrestrial depositional settings, and whether standard sampling methods are sufficient to obtain unaltered rock material. We tested the fidelity of the terrestrial δ13Corg record with respect to surficial alteration and contamination through investigation of different field sampling techniques, including hand trenches, a backhoe-excavated trench, and sediment coring. We find that δ13Corg values in hand and backhoe trenched sections are more positive than δ13Corg values in cored sections, implying that modern surficial alteration affects δ13Corg values but not overall trends. A negative δ13Corg excursion associated with the KPB is present in most sections we analyzed, but it does not appear to be unique within our sections. The KPB excursion occurs within a coal layer, and we observe similar excursions within other carbon-rich lithologies. Given that we cannot disentangle local lithological effects from global atmospheric changes, we conclude that a negative δ13Corg excursion is not an unequivocal indicator of the KPB in the Hell Creek area.