Analysis of recombination and mutation events for 12 X-Chr STR loci: A collaborative family study of the Italian Speaking Working Group Ge.F.I

Abstract

According to the ISFG guidelines on the use of X-chromosome, the biostatistical evaluation in kinship analysis is based on a likelihood ratio approach, but since in calculation linkage and recombination events should be accounted for, an accurate estimate of mutation and recombination rates of X-markers analyzed is required. Due to the mode of genetic transmission and physical location, sometimes X-chromosome markers can be more informative than autosomal STRs and their analysis could be considered a supplementary tool in DNA testing.The increased demand to forensic laboratories for kinship investigations in complex cases explains the need not only to enlarge the Italian population database for 12 X-STRs routinely used for forensic application, but also to investigate the recombination fractions among markers.A collaborative exercise of the Italian Speaking Working Group Ge.F.I. was organized to evaluate mutation and recombination events in 12 X-STRs included in the Investigator Argus X12 kit. In order to explore the segregation stability, three-generation families (grandpa-mother-son) and two-generation families (mother-sons, father-daughters) for a total of 269 pedigrees were analyzed and calculations to estimate the recombination fractions between pairs of markers and mutation rates were performed. The statistical analysis showed evidence of inter- and intra-cluster recombination events, with almost free recombination for junction markers of linkage groups I and II and reduced recombination for linkage groups III and VI. We observed one- and two-step mutations, with an average value of 2.9 × 10−3.