Analysis of flow shop scheduling anomalies

Abstract

Anomalies in flow shop scheduling are rare; only two anomalies have been reported. We present five new anomalies for the permutation flow shop models with the minimum makespan objective and seven more anomalies for the minimum total flow time objective. These anomalies (including the existing ones) are divided into three types corresponding to an increased processing time of a single operation, the addition of a job and the addition of a machine. We derive two properties which, when satisfied, eliminate the possibility of certain anomalies. We conclude that restrictions such as no-delay schedules, no job waiting or no machine idle time (after it starts processing) often result in anomalies. We also show that anomalies can also occur in non-permutation flow shops (four new anomalies presented).