Analysing the impact of bottom trawls on sedimentary seabeds with sediment profile imagery

Abstract

Sediment profile imagery (SPI) was evaluated for the assessment of otter trawling impacts on the seabed. This technique allows the imaging of the topmost sediment layers in profile, including the sediment–water interface. Two areas in the Aegean Sea were investigated in time series, each with control and impact areas: a commercial fishing lane with soft sediments at approximately 200 m depth and an experimentally trawled lane with harder maerly sediments at approximately 80 m depth. In total, 158 images were taken at the deep ground and 124 at the shallow ground. A number of measurements were taken from each image, leading to estimates of comparative penetration and small-scale seabed surface roughness. In addition, a large number of surface and subsurface attributes were noted in the images to form the basis of a multivariate analysis. Results indicated that penetration and roughness by themselves were not very good indicators, although roughness was a better indicator particularly in coarse sediments. The major reason for this is that the measurements alone (in particular roughness) do not distinguish between biological and anthropogenic disturbance. The multivariate analysis combining the measurements with the attributes was a good indicator in investigating trawling impacts in coarse sediments, where the lack of good penetration can be compensated by the view over the sediment surface, where more attribute-type data can be gathered. The SPI sampling window gives a relatively small imaged sample in comparison to other imaging techniques (side scan sonar, video, etc.) and in a heterogeneous environment, the more the replicates, the more reliable the method will be. A tiered imaging approach is recommended where more than one methodology is used.