Analyses of electron and proton scattering to low-excitation isoscalar states in 20Ne, 24Mg and 28Si

Abstract

The excitation of low-lying isoscalar 2 + and 4 + states in 20Ne, 24Mg and 28Si by electron and proton scattering is studied. Large basis models of nuclear structure are used to determine both the electromagnetic and hadronic transition densities. The analyses of the longitudinal form factors obtained from electron scattering show that little or no effective charges are required with these nuclear structure models. Proton inelastic scattering to these states then is analysed to test effective forces based upon the Paris and Hamada-Johnston interactions. At intermediate energies (155 MeV) density-dependent t-matrices from both potentials were used with fits to data giving a clear preference for that based upon the Paris interaction. For lower energies only the Hamada-Johnston t-matrix is available and comparison of analyses of 24 and 49 MeV data made using this (complex) t-matrix with those in which the (real) Paris G-matrix is used as the effective force show a clear preference for the t-matrix. This is particularly the case with analyses of polarization data and suggests that the use of the G-matrix as an effective force in nuclear reaction calculations is inadequate even at low energies.