Anaesthetists' and surgeons' attitudes towards informed consent in the UK: an observational study

Aab Jamjoom,Ik Moppett,S White,Sm Walton,Jg Hardman

doi:10.1186/1472-6939-11-2

Aab Jamjoom, Ik Moppett + Show 3 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6939-11-2

Copy DOI

Abstract

BackgroundThe attitudes of patients' to consent have changed over the years, but there has been little systematic study of the attitudes of anaesthetists and surgeons in this process. We aimed to describe observations made on the attitudes of medical professionals working in the UK to issues surrounding informed consent.MethodA questionnaire made up of 35 statements addressing the process of consent for anaesthesia and surgery was distributed to randomly selected anaesthetists and surgeons in Queen's Medical Centre (Nottingham), Royal Sussex County Hospital (Brighton) and Eastbourne District General Hospital (Eastbourne) during 2007. Participants were asked to what extent they agreed with statements regarding consent.ResultsOf 234 questionnaires distributed, 63% were returned. Of the respondents 79% agreed that the main purpose of the consent process is to respect patient autonomy. While 55% of the examined cohort agreed that the consent process maybe inappropriate as patients do not usually remember all the information given to them. Furthermore, 84% of the participants agreed that what the procedure aims to achieve should be explained to the patient during the consent process. While of the participants, over 70% agreed that major risks of incidence greater than 1/100 should be disclosed to the patient as part of the consent process.ConclusionsThe majority of respondents appear to hold attitudes in standing with current guidelines on informed consent however there was still a significant minority who held more paternalistic views to the consent process bringing into question the need for further training in the area.

Highlights

The attitudes of patients’ to consent have changed over the years, but there has been little systematic study of the attitudes of anaesthetists and surgeons in this process
With regard to the primary questions [Table 2], 79% of participants agreed with the statement that the main purpose of the consent process is to respect patient autonomy
While 55% of the examined cohort agreed that the consent process maybe inappropriate as patients do not usually remember all the information given to them

Summary

Introduction

The attitudes of patients’ to consent have changed over the years, but there has been little systematic study of the attitudes of anaesthetists and surgeons in this process. Heightened awareness has led to a considerable amount of medical research into the consent process. A number of studies have looked at consent in a particular setting such as in intensive care [8], medical research [9], plastic surgery [10], interventional radiology [11] and paediatric surgery [12], or in managing a specific problem such as laparoscopic cholecystectomy [13] and emergency abdominal surgery [14]. The authors felt it was appropriate to study the attitudes of anaesthetists and surgeons towards the entire process of consent in the UK. Our aim was to assess whether surgeons’ and anaesthetists’ attitudes towards consent were in standing with current national guidelines

Objectives

Methods

Results

Conclusion