An Investigation on Reasons Causing Inferiority in Unlubricated Sliding Wear Performance of 60NiTi as Compared to 440C Steel

Abstract

60NiTi is gaining recognition as an alternative to 440C steel in ball bearing components due to its intrinsic corrosion resistance and unusually high static load capacity. 440C steel and 60NiTi exhibit comparable Rockwell hardness and would be expected to exhibit similar sliding wear behavior using hardness based models. However, results show that under unlubricated sliding conditions, 60NiTi shows inferior wear properties than 440C steel. In this study, a series of indentation and single pass scratching experiments are conducted to elucidate the reasons behind this unexpected observation. Moreover, sliding wear tests carried out under moderate and extreme tensile stress conditions were used to identify sliding conditions under which these materials exhibit similar and dissimilar behavior. The results show that 440C steel exhibits more microscopic plasticity than 60NiTi, halting the propagation of generated tensile microcracks. In contrast, the intrinsic brittleness of 60NiTi leads to the formation and growth of microcracks between the shear bands causing subsequent wear particle generation. These lead to the occurrence of wear through more aggressive abrasion processes in 60NiTi than 440C steel. These findings help explain why 60NiTi performs well when lubricated. 60NiTi is expected to tolerate ∼912 MPa tensile stress before yielding. Under good lubricated conditions where a perfect lubricating film is formed, friction induced tensile stresses fall below the tensile strength of 60NiTi and wear is prevented. However, inadequate lubrication combined with high contact stress leads to damage and wear.