An Investigation of High-Z Material for Bolus in Electron Beam Therapy

Abstract

Electron beams are frequently used for superficial tumors including: primary skin cancers, surgical scars, cutaneous lymphomas and benign conditions like keloids. However, due to electron beam characteristics the surface dose is 75-95% of the prescribed dose depending on beam energy thus requiring placement of bolus to augment surface dose. Various types of boluses; wet gauge/towel, superflab, superstuff, aquaplast, 3D printed plastics, customized dot-decimal bolus, thermoshield, brass and tantalum wire mesh are commonly used in clinics with variable difficulties that are not perfect. As majority of these devices do not snug to the skin contour and create air-gap that is known to produce significant dose perturbations creating hot and cold spot. The variable dosimetry has cosmetic implications and potentially increased risk of recurrence. A new cloth-like high-Z materials; Tungsten, (Z = 74) and Bismuth, (Z = 83) impregnated with silicone gel are now commercially available which is investigated in this study for bolus purpose. Commercially available, super soft silicone-gel based submillimeter thin Tungsten and Bismuth sheets were investigated for bolus properties in electron beams in the range of 6-12 MeV using 10x10 cm2 applicator. These materials were tested on various body contour for perfect snug without any air traps. Using parallel plate ion chamber measurements were performed in a solid water phantom on a medical linear accelerator machine. Depth dose characteristics were measured to optimize the thickness for surface dose to be 100% for selected electron therapy. Surface dose for a 10x10 cm2 cone for 6, 9, 12 MeV beams were measured to be 75.1%, 80.1% and 86.2%, respectively. Silicone-gel Tungsten and Bismuth sheets produce significant electrons thus increasing surface dose. Based on measured depth dose, our data showed that Tungsten sheets of 0.14 mm, 0.18 mm and 0.2 mm and Bismuth sheets of 0.42 mm, 0.18 mm and 0.2 mm provide 100% surface dose for 6, 9 and 12 MeV beams, respectively without any changes in depth dose except increasing surface dose. The new Tungsten and Bismuth based silicone-gel clothlike sheets are extremely soft but high tensile metallic bolus materials that can fit flawlessly on any skin contour without any air trap or variable thickness or spillage of the water as in conventionally used wet gauge. Only 0.2 mm thick sheets are needed for 100% surface dose without degradation of the depth dose characteristics. These materials are reusable and ideal for bolus in electron beam treatment. This investigation opens a new frontier in designing new bolus materials optimum for patient treatment.