An international comparison of Long-term Care Facility outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Abstract Background The COVID-19 pandemic has had huge repercussions for public health internationally and different countries had different outcomes based on preconceived policy interventions. Lessons influencing future policy have been learned, notably how best to manage vulnerable populations, particularly those living in long-term care facilities (LTCFs). In Ireland LTCF residents accounted for 56% of deaths during the first wave of the pandemic and it is imperative to establish the causes of this. International research has highlighted how factors including county incidence rate, facility size, occupancy, LTCF ownership and compliance with health inspection regulations influenced LTCF COVID-19 outcomes. The aim of this research is to explore the impact of these factors in an Irish context and compare to best international standards. Methods The main outcome considered was deaths per 100 beds. Data on crude mortality were available for 580 Irish LTCFs up to 28 May 2020. Data regarding occupancy, ownership, facility size and compliance with regulations were obtained for these LTCFs from a novel dataset of 1130 available LTCF regulatory inspection reports between 2018- 2022. Regression analysis was carried out to show how LTCF mortality was predicted by examined variables. Results The most significant predictor of deaths from COVID-19 in Irish LTCFs resulting from this research was LTCF occupancy (Odds ratio:1.029, significance <0.001). Regional community incidence, in concordance with international literature was also an important factor. Other stated predictors in this model were either non-significant or only marginally significant. These results are analysed in conversation with international research of the same variables. Conclusions To protect LTCF residents for potential future pandemics, attention should be paid to monitoring and suppressing local incidence rates and moves should be implemented towards designing smaller facilities with individual rooms for vulnerable residents. Key messages • Irish long-term care pandemic mortality was predicted by high occupancy of facilities and high regional COVID-19 incidence. • Comparing International COVID-19 outcomes in long-term care facilities can provide guidelines for the future.