An Integrated Case Study for Evaluating the Impacts of an Oil Refinery Effluent on Aquatic Biota in the Delaware River: Sediment Core Studies

Abstract

ABSTRACT The objectives of this study were to (1) determine if historical exceedences of oil and grease concentrations above the limits allowed in the National Pollution Elimination Discharge System permit for the wastewater treatment facility of Motiva Enterprises LLC Refinery, Delaware City, Delaware, could be determined from the sedimentary records of the Delaware River and, if so, (2) were the concentrations of contaminants high enough to be toxic to aquatic biota. Eighty-four surficial sediment samples, both within and outside the influence of the Refinery's discharge plume, were initially evaluated for their appropriateness for coring. Seven stations were ultimately selected for the historical core studies. Based on sediment type, radionuclide (Pb-210, Cs-137 and Be-7) geochronologies, and proximity of the cores to the Refinery, two cores were selected for more detailed polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) analyses. The rapid accumulation area of one core (located in the near-field of the discharge plume) had maximum total PAH (TPAH) concentration peaks at depths of 4 cm (1997; 3100 ng/g dw) and at 8.5–9 cm (1993; 3200 ng/g dw); the second core (located on the far-field periphery of the plume) had a maximum TPAH peak at 6.5 cm (1997; 3200 ng/g dw). In all cases, the maximum TPAH concentrations were below NOAA's Effects Range-Low concentration of 4022 ng/g dw for sediment biota toxicity. A chemical fingerprinting analysis of the PAHs in the two cores showed, however, that the PAHs present in the cores were predominantly pyrogenic PAHs consistent with Delaware River background PAHs. The core results are consistent with historic sediment PAH inputs in an industrial river system. PAH from the Refinery, if present, exist as a non-detectable increment to a high PAH baseline from many sources.