An initial experimental assessment of the influence of substrate depth on floral assemblage for extensive green roofs

Abstract

Extensive green roofs have the potential to be used as mitigation tools to compensate for urban habitat loss, but there is little information about how closely these systems emulate ground-based habitats. This study investigated the effect of limited substrate depth on plant assemblages in the initial phase of growth in extensive green roof substrates. Five replicate mesocosms (1 m 2) for each of three design treatments: (A) 10 cm aggregate depth with green roof drainage and solid floor, (B) 15 cm aggregate depth with green roof drainage and solid floor, and (C) 15 cm aggregate depth on top of bare earth; were positioned at ground level. Each mesocosm had an identical growth substrate and was seeded with the same seed mix. Plant assemblages were analysed using point-quadrat methods. Significant differences in species composition were observed between treatments that seemed to be related to water availability. Even the deep (15 cm) solid floor green roof treatment showed many significant differences in floral assemblage compared to the identical treatment (C) where plants had access to water in the soil profile. Therefore, it is not possible to exactly recreate most ground-based urban habitats on roofs by simply copying the soil characteristics and floral composition found on the ground. Like for mitigation for habitat loss using extensive green roofs requires the careful manipulation of design elements in order to counteract the limited water availability on green roofs.