An experimental inactivated virus vaccine against bovine ephemeral fever 2. Do neutralizing antibodies protect against infection?

Abstract

In order to develop a safe vaccine against bovine ephemeral fever (BEF) which could be used in areas normally free of the disease, studies were carried out on inactivated virus vaccines. Initial experiments were carried out in cattle using virus vaccines that had been inactivated with β-propiolactone or formalin and then made-up in aluminium phosphate gel or Freund's incomplete adjuvant. A minimum inactivated virus dose of 10 6 PFU was necessary to stimulate a serum neutralizing antibody response in cattle. β-propiolactone inactivated BEF virus vaccines in Freund's incomplete adjuvant gave the best serum neutralizing antibody responses, producing high levels of neutralizing antibody with both high and low passage level virus. However, the magnitude of the antibody response bore little relationship to resistance of vaccinated animals to challenge with virulent BEF virus. A number of animals with high neutralizing antibody titres to BEF virus did not resist challenge. Using 500-fold less live virus at equivalent passage level to the low passage inactivated vaccine, similar or slightly lower antibody levels were attained, but most of the animals resisted challenge. It is suggested that the nature of the immune response and resistance to BEF infection may be complex and that reliance on serum neutralizing antibody as an indicator of resistance may give misleading results.