An experimental comparison of methods to use methanol and Jatropha oil in a compression ignition engine

Abstract

In this work various methods of using vegetable oil (Jatropha oil) and methanol such as blending, transesterification and dual fuel operation were studied experimentally. A single cylinder direct injection diesel engine was used for this work. Tests were done at constant speed of 1500 rev min −1 at varying power outputs. In dual fuel operation the methanol to Jatropha oil ratio was maintained at 3:7 on the volume basis. This is close to the fraction of methanol used to prepare the ester with Jatropha oil. Brake thermal efficiency was better in the dual fuel operation and with the methyl ester of Jatropha oil as compared to the blend. It increased form 27.4% with neat Jatropha oil to a maximum of 29% with the methyl ester and 28.7% in the dual fuel operation. Smoke was reduced with all methods compared to neat vegetable oil operation. The values of smoke emission are 4.4 Bosch Smoke Units (BSU) with neat Jatropha oil, 4.1 BSU with the blend, 4 BSU with methyl ester of Jatropha oil and 3.5 BSU in the dual fuel operation. The Nitric Oxide (NO) level was lower with Jatropha oil compared to diesel. It was further reduced in dual fuel operation and the blend with methanol. Dual fuel operation showed higher hydrocarbon (HC) and carbon monoxide (CO) emissions than the ester and the blend. Ignition delay was higher with neat Jatropha oil. It increased further with the blend and in dual fuel operation. It was reduced with the ester. Peak pressure and rate of pressure rise were higher with all the methods compared to neat Jatropha oil operation. Jatropha oil and methyl ester showed higher diffusion combustion compared to standard diesel operation. However, dual fuel operation resulted in higher premixed combustion. On the whole it is concluded that transesterification of vegetable oils and methanol induction can significantly enhance the performance of a vegetable oil fuelled diesel engine.