An evaluation of water extraction as a soil-testing procedure for phosphorus I. Glasshouse assessment of plant-available phosphorus

Abstract

A water extraction procedure was evaluated as a soil-testing procedure for phosphorus (P). In a glasshouse experiment using perennial ryegrass, the water extraction procedure was used to predict plant-available P in 20 New Zealand soils varying widely in P status and P retention capacity. Water-extractable P in the 20 soils was highly correlated with plant uptake of P (r = 0.90**). Although plant uptake of P and Olsen-extractable P were equally well correlated (r = 0.90**), relationships between plant uptake of P and Bray1 — and Truog-extractable P, and isotopically exchangeable P were less close. The prediction of plant-available P using water extraction was not improved by inclusion of an estimate of P-buffering capacity (obtained from P retention capacity or the slope of the P desorption isotherm), in contrast to the finding for Olsen-extractable P. Because the interpretation of the results obtained appears to be independent of P-buffering capacity and soil type, the water extraction procedure may have advantages over the other soil-testing procedures for P for soils containing reasonable amounts of water-extractable P.