Abstract

The central issue of this paper is to explore the possibilities of SNA (Social Network Analysis) for detecting scientific schools and academic networks in the university through its application to the bibliometric doctoral dissertations presented in Spanish universities between 1970 and 2002. Furthermore, the development, thematic, institutional and geographic profile of the doctoral dissertations read in Spain in this period is established; key players in the birth of university research groups are identified and finally academic genealogies are traced. The TESEO database has been used to identify the bibliometric dissertations and composition of examining boards. The following variables have been studied: number of dissertations by year, center and university of thesis defense, subject, units of analysis, thesis advisor, participation in examination committees, advisor-candidate genealogies and information sources. The total number of dissertations produced during the studied period was 213. A fast growth in the number of dissertations read in this period is observed. At the beginning the University of Valencia produced the majority of these. Later, during a second stage, this university was replaced by other institutions such as Murcia, Complutense, Granada and Valladolid, all of them with similar results. The subject and faculty analysis confirms a very close relationship between Bibliometrics and Medicine; this being the discipline which uses it most, followed by Psychology. During the last years of the period LIS studies gained in strength. The SNA indicators highlight Lopez Pinero’s role as a pioneer in the introduction of Bibliometrics in Spain and reveal how he spread his ideas among different actors which at a later stage occupied outstanding positions; but during the last years of the period studied they were displaced by new schools and researchers which are more polyvalent, like Elias Sanz Casado. The structural analysis shows five schools: Valencia-Murcia in Medicine, Valladolid, Valencia in Psychology, Madrid and Granada.

Highlights

  • The central issue of this paper is to explore the possibilities of SNA (Social Network Analysis) for detecting scientific schools and academic networks in the university through its application to the bibliometric doctoral dissertations presented in Spanish universities between 1970 and 2002

  • The development, thematic, institutional and geographic profile of the doctoral dissertations read in Spain in this period is established; key players in the birth of university research groups are identified and academic genealogies are traced

  • Later, during a second stage, this university was replaced by other institutions such as Murcia, Complutense, Granada and Valladolid, all of them with similar results

Read more

Summary

Introducción

Desde la perspectiva de la investigación, son buenos documentos para caracterizar la investigación original en un campo. En España, aunque mucho más recientemente, el ARS se ha utilizado tanto para el estudio de la colaboración científica a través de la coautoría [34] como para analizar los efectos estructurantes de la política de I+D sobre un campo de investigación [35], las estructuras emergentes, y sus propiedades para la difusión del conocimiento y la innovación, la colaboración en la ejecución de proyectos de I+D [36] o las redes de poder anidadas en tribunales de oposiciones [37]. Para ello se ha aplicado el análisis de redes sociales al estudio de las tesis doctorales sobre Bibliometría leídas en la universidad española entre 1976 y 2002 a partir del estudio de la composición de los tribunales que han de juzgar dichas tesis. Con este estudio se pretende determinar la evolución, el perfil temático, institucional, y geográfico de las tesis bibliométricas leídas en la universidad española entre 1976 y 2002 así como identificar a los protagonistas en la gestación de los focos de investigación Bibliométrica y fijar posibles genealogías académicas

Material y métodos
Evolución en la producción de tesis
Universidades de lectura
Facultades de lectura
Temática: unidades de análisis y disciplinas
Directores y genealogía de tesis
Presencia en tribunales
Redes de coparticipación en tribunales
Estructura reticular de coparticipación en tribunales
Análisis estructural de directores y selección de sus tribunales
Análisis de la afiliación miembro tribunal-Universidad de lectura
Conclusiones
Findings
Bibliografía
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call