An Almost Optimal Algorithm for Computing Nonnegative Rank

Abstract

Here, we give an algorithm for deciding if the nonnegative rank of a matrix $M$ of dimension $m \times n$ is at most $r$ which runs in time $(nm)^{O(r^2)}$. This is the first exact algorithm that runs in time singly exponential in $r$. This algorithm (and earlier algorithms) are built on methods for finding a solution to a system of polynomial inequalities (if one exists). Notably, the best algorithms for this task run in time exponential in the number of variables but polynomial in all of the other parameters (the number of inequalities and the maximum degree). Hence, these algorithms motivate natural algebraic questions whose solution have immediate algorithmic implications: How many variables do we need to represent the decision problem, and does $M$ have nonnegative rank at most $r$? A naive formulation uses $nr + mr$ variables and yields an algorithm that is exponential in $n$ and $m$ even for constant $r$. Arora et al. [Proceedings of STOC, 2012, pp. 145--162] recently reduced the number of variables to $2r^2 2^r$, and here we exponentially reduce the number of variables to $2r^2$ and this yields our main algorithm. In fact, the algorithm that we obtain is nearly optimal (under the exponential time hypothesis) since an algorithm that runs in time $(nm)^{o(r)}$ would yield a subexponential algorithm for $3$-SAT [Proceedings of STOC, 2012, pp. 145--162]. Our main result is based on establishing a normal form for nonnegative matrix factorization---which in turn allows us to exploit algebraic dependence among a large collection of linear transformations with variable entries. Additionally, we also demonstrate that nonnegative rank cannot be certified by even a very large submatrix of $M$, and this property also follows from the intuition gained from viewing nonnegative rank through the lens of systems of polynomial inequalities.