Aminoacyl thiol esters and the origins of genetic specificity

Abstract

Reasons for believing that primitive mechanisms of translation may have employed thiol esters of the amino acids rather than oxygen esters are summarized. It is suggested that coenzyme A (HSCoA), which fulfills the role of aminoacyl transfer in the synthesis of peptide antibiotics, is a primitive analogue of tRNA which performs a similar role in protein synthesis. HSCoA—an adenylic acid moiety containing phosphates esterified at the 3′ and 5′ positions and linked to a peptide-like structure terminating in a reactive thiol—possesses chemical features suggestive of both peptides and polynucleotides. Examination of the chemistry of HSCoA-like molecules shows that a rather similar compound can carry out a repeating intramolecular peptide synthesis in the absence of enzymes. Condensation of further nucleotides onto the adenylic acid moiety gives rise to parallel modes of peptide and oligonucleotide synthesis. A “self-improving” ability to select available amino acids is inherent in the proposed mechanism of peptide synthesis. The hypothesis plausibly explains the universal occurrence of a sulphur-containing amino acid at the N terminus of nascent proteins.